Ken Davy: "Taking a weather check on pension freedoms" Ken Davy: "Taking a weather check on pension freedoms"

02 Aug 2017

BBC weatherman Michael Fish famously failed to forecast the hurricane in October 1987, which overnight destroyed 15m trees and turned the town of Sevenoaks into just one oak.
I therefore take no pleasure in being proved right about the inherent dangers of pension freedoms, which I warned would inevitably lead to consumer detriment. Introduced more as a political expedient than a carefully thought through policy, the pension freedoms chickens are now coming home to roost, with serious financial consequences for advisers and consumers.

Somewhat belatedly, we are now seeing a flurry of regulatory activity around the dangers of transfers from defined benefit schemes. In addition, it is clear that many thousands of consumers are transferring savings from secure, well-managed and tax-efficient defined contribution schemes and personal pensions into inefficient bank accounts or similar, paying low or even no interest, while often creating an unforeseen tax bill in the process.

We are now seeing a flurry of regulatory activity around the dangers of transfers from defined benefit schemes
We are also starting to see the results of the actions of the minority of advisers whose irresponsible, reckless and – in some cases – criminal behaviour has facilitated wholly inappropriate pension transfers.

It is no coincidence that the FCA is issuing warnings about how to deal with pension freedoms at the same time as numerous clients are being referred to the FSCS.

The ultimate cost to the FSCS of this reckless behaviour is not yet known. However, we do know that until the funding of the FSCS has been reformed, the cost will fall wholly unfairly on the adviser community.

Once again it will be the responsible, compliant and well-governed advice firms that have to pick up the bill for the actions of a small minority of careless, reckless or criminal advisers. My forecast is not about us facing a hurricane, but rather that as a result of pension freedom we will see an avalanche of claims on the FSCS.

I believe most of these problems could have been avoided if the government had consulted properly before introducing pension freedoms. If it had, we could have all enjoyed pension freedoms that delivered better outcomes for consumers, advisers, regulators and the government.

Ken Davy is chairman of SimplyBiz Group


Testimonials

"In a world of image-is-everything, I have come across many a recruitment agent over the years. Promises not fulfilled, comments not substantiated, systems/procedures that don't manifest themselves. Instead what I have found with you and SimplyBiz is, above all, integrity. What you have said has been based on experience and knowledge and, accordingly, has been based on facts. Facts that have, of course, transpired to be true. The ability to rely on those who know what the DA application process is all about is impossible to cost, but important to value."

Derek Avenell
Hawthorn Financial Services

Read More

Latest News

Government must help meet the needs of the elderly

October 11, 2017

Being able to congratulate the FCA, while not by any means a first, is not something I am able to do regularly.

Read more >

"A princely way of looking at succession issues"

October 04, 2017

Seeing all the stories about Prince George starting school set me thinking about longevity and business succession issues for financial advisers.

Read more >

"Providers must allow tax deductible advice"

September 28, 2017

Knock, knock. Are you there? More importantly, are you listening?
I ask this question because of the enormous opportunities the current market is presenting for each and every adviser, whether working within a large firm or a one-person practice, as an independent adviser or restricted.

Read more >

Fos report is a dollop of gruel for advisers

September 19, 2017

Cold porridge and cold comfort have a lot in common: such meagre offerings do not come close to being satisfying.

Read more >